Dreaming of a Caribbean getaway but worried about safety? A new travel ranking has you covered. The Caribbean Island Safety Index 2025 just revealed its results, and Aruba has claimed the top spot.
This report considered crime levels, hurricane risk, healthcare quality, and government advisories. As a frequent traveler in this region, I can tell you those factors make all the difference between a carefree vacation, and one filled with stress.
So, which islands are safest for 2025? Let’s click through the list.
Aruba (Score: 9.3)
Aruba emerges as a leader, boasting some of the strongest safety ratings in the region. It faces virtually no hurricane risk, crime rates are low, and healthcare standards are comparable to those in the Netherlands. Add to that a U.S. advisory of “Exercise Normal Precautions,” and you can relax knowing safety is part of the package.
Barbados (Score: 9.2)
Barbados earns second place with high marks in safety and strong infrastructure. The island is known for its warm hospitality and polished tourism scene, making it a reliable choice for visitors.
Grenada (Score: 9.0)
Grenada, the Spice Island, is famous for its nutmeg and cinnamon, but is now also recognized for its strong safety reputation. Scores across the board make it one of the most secure destinations for travelers looking for both relaxation and adventure.
Curaçao (Score: 9.0)
Tied with Grenada, Curaçao blends European influence with Caribbean charm. Its low crime rates and established international community make it a welcoming destination for families and solo travelers alike.
Antigua & Barbuda (Score: 8.1)
Antigua and Barbuda deliver plenty of safety along with 365 beaches, one for every day of the year. Although its score is slightly lower than that of the top four, it remains an excellent choice for beach lovers.
Puerto Rico (Score: 7.6)
Puerto Rico ranks in the middle, but its proximity to the U.S. makes it a popular destination for U.S. travelers. While some urban areas require caution, tourist zones and resorts have seen steady investment and remain secure.
Dominican Republic (Score: 7.0)
The Dominican Republic is a major tourism hub with a wide range of all-inclusive resorts. Although it falls in the middle of the rankings, sticking to tourist areas and following advisories helps ensure a safe trip.
Saint Lucia (Score: 6.8)
With its dramatic Piton mountains and luxury resorts, Saint Lucia remains a favorite for romantic getaways. Some neighborhoods require caution, but most resorts and tourist destinations are well-managed and safe.
The Bahamas (Score: 6.5)
The Bahamas attracts millions of visitors each year, but faces some safety concerns that have lowered its ranking. Cruise ports and family-friendly resorts continue to offer secure options for visitors who want the classic island experience.
Jamaica (Score: 5.5)
Jamaica is world-renowned for its culture and natural beauty, but it ranks last on this year’s safety list. Visitors are encouraged to stay within resorts and book excursions through trusted providers to enjoy the best of the island with peace of mind.
Safety Tips for the Caribbean
Even on the safest islands, it pays to travel smart. Keep your passport and valuables in the hotel safe, use licensed taxis or ride-sharing services, and avoid carrying large amounts of cash. Sticking to tourist zones and well-lit areas at night adds peace of mind, no matter where you go.
Best Time to Visit Safest Islands
Timing matters almost as much as location. Aruba, sitting outside the hurricane belt, is a year-round winner. For Barbados, Grenada, and Curaçao, the sweet spot is late spring or early fall when prices dip but the weather stays warm. Traveling in these windows saves money and helps you avoid the peak-season crowds.
The Bottom Line for Caribbean Travelers
Safety might not be the first thing travelers picture when planning a Caribbean escape. Still, it is always the foundation of a truly relaxing trip. Aruba’s number one ranking is no surprise given its calm environment and strong infrastructure.
Whether you choose the laid-back charm of Barbados, the spice-scented breezes of Grenada, or the easy access of Puerto Rico, this list shows there are plenty of safe options for a 2025 getaway. With the proper planning, you can focus less on worry and more on sunshine.
For more smart travel tips and tricks, check out our full collection of guides to make your next trip smoother, no matter where you fly from.