The Best Pie Shops in America to Celebrate National Strawberry Cream Pie Day

Strawberry cream pie has its moment on September 28, but the real story is America’s love affair with pie in all its forms.

From iconic apple to innovative chocolate creations, these legendary pie shops keep traditions alive while tempting taste buds nationwide. Here are the bakeries every pie lover should know.

Four & Twenty Blackbirds (Brooklyn, New York)

Founded by sisters Emily and Melissa Elsen, this Brooklyn hotspot revolutionized the pie scene with innovative flavors like Salted Caramel Apple, Black Bottom Oatmeal, and Matcha Custard.

Their rotating seasonal menu has made them one of the most influential modern pie shops in the country.

Achatz Handmade Pie Co. (Armada, Michigan)

This Michigan favorite is renowned for its use of local fruit and family recipes. The Michigan 4-Berry, Caramel Nut Apple, and Cannoli Cream pies are fan favorites, all made with organic flour and hormone-free butter.

It’s an authentic taste of Midwest tradition.

Pie Junkie (Oklahoma City, Oklahoma)

With its retro flair and surprising flavors, Pie Junkie has become a local legend. Standouts include the Drunken Turtle, Bird Dog Buttermilk, and Pineapple Millionaire.

The shop produces thousands of handmade pies each year, keeping locals coming back for more.

Dangerously Delicious Pies (Baltimore, Maryland)

Founded by musician Rodney Henry, this edgy pie shop is renowned for its indulgent creations, including the Baltimore Bomb, The King, and Mobtown Brown.

With more than 50 flavors on the menu, it’s as much about creativity as it is about comfort food.